Before You Go to Thrive: athenaOne Marketplace Q3 Data
Max Alsgaard-Miller, an athenahealth marketplace consultant who spent eleven years inside the company, on what his Q3 marketplace data says about AI adoption, integration choices, and how practices can evaluate partners before Thrive.
With Max Alsgaard-Miller, athenahealth Marketplace Consultant
Key takeaways
- The marketplace began as a way to bring potential disruptors onto the athenahealth platform, and it continues to create room for new partners.
- AI is changing both what marketplace partners can build and how quickly new companies can enter the ecosystem.
- Chrome extensions, RPA, and API integrations have different trade-offs; practices should understand how a partner connects to their workflows.
- Going deep on one EHR can matter more than claiming broad support across many platforms.
- Marketplace ratings need context: the volume and recency of reviews can tell a different story from the average score.
Before heading to Thrive, Kevin sits down with Max Alsgaard-Miller to look at what is actually happening inside the athenaOne marketplace. Max spent eleven years at athenahealth across implementation, product, operations, and marketplace marketing. Now he advises marketplace partners and tracks how the ecosystem is changing over time.
How the marketplace got here
Max traces the marketplace back to Jonathan Bush and Clayton Christensen’s “more disruption please” experiment: invite companies onto the platform rather than wait for them to displace it. He and Kevin discuss how that idea evolved and why the marketplace continues to attract new partners.
AI changes who can build
The conversation turns to the companies that joined after ChatGPT launched and the problems AI makes possible to solve. Max distinguishes between lowering the barrier to building software and finding new ways to address work that previously depended on people.
Integration choices show up in practice workflows
Chrome extensions and robotic process automation can work around gaps, but changes to the underlying interface can break them. Max and Kevin compare those trade-offs with API integrations, discuss what happens when athenahealth builds a feature a partner already sells, and explore why going deep on one platform can matter more than listing every EHR.
Reading the Q3 data
Max walks through his Q3 marketplace report, including growth in AI phone agents and the revenue cycle management trends that a headline number can hide. He also explains why practices should look beyond an average star rating to the number of reviews and how recently customers left them.
What comes next
They close with Max’s outlook for the next five to ten years: more RPA, pressure to make clinical and billing data more accessible, and the growing competition between payer AI and provider AI.
Listen to the episode on Spotify.
Explore Max’s marketplace intelligence report and his work with athenahealth marketplace partners.
Transcript
Read the full transcript
And that was that was the core functionality was the athenaCollector Rules Engine.
So you'd think that that is that's the sacred thing. That's the core at the center, it's the nucleus of of what they've built. But when we look at the data, there are a lot of revenue cycle companies that are on the athenahealth marketplace now. And that is fascinating because that means that people have found better ways to do the core offering that athenahealth originally came to market with.
You're listening to the Pretty Good AI podcast.
Today's guest, Max, has spent more time inside the athenahealth Marketplace than anyone who's not employed by athenahealth. And he just published his Q3 read on where the whole ecosystem stands.
Everyone in this space has an opinion about the athenahealth marketplace if you're building for ambulatory practices or outpatient.
Here at Pretty Good AI, we only focus on athenahealth practices and have been building exclusively on athenahealth for the better part of two years. Everyone in this space has an opinion on where the athenahealth marketplace is going, but Max actually has the data. 565 partners tracked over time.
we'll get into what the data says.
And Max's history of where the marketplace started and how he thinks it's going to evolve over time.
Let's get into it.
Max, welcome to the Pretty Good AI podcast. You spent over a decade inside athenahealth, you know, across product, implementation, ops, and marketplace marketing. And now spend all your time sort of helping companies figure out like how to actually win on the marketplace. And so, you know, excited to talk. Your Q3 report just came out. And so maybe let's use that as like a spine for like a conversation. But before we do that, would love to kind of, you know, get into some of your background.
Yeah, absolutely. Well, thanks for having me on the pod, Kevin. so as we said, I worked at or currently I advise companies that are on the athenahealth marketplace on their product strategy and their go-to-market strategy. before that, I spent over a decade at athenahealth. I started out on the implementation side of things. I traveled around the country and did implementation and optimization for over a hundred clinics.
I went into marketing for the marketplace. And that's when I really started to get deeper into the marketplace side of things. Got to see all of these companies, how they were bringing their solutions, how it was fitting with athenahealth, where it wasn't fitting with athenahealth, and how they could use help for telling their stories.
And then I left and started this consulting business that I've been working with Marketplace Partners ever since.
Awesome, man. This is cool. And so I think the state of the athenahealth marketplace has obviously changed, I'm sure, a lot from your, initial times at athenahealth till today. But maybe let's just jump all the way to the present. Your Q3 report just came out. what's changed since Q two and and what surprised you?
Yeah, so the athenahealth Marketplace has just continued to grow and grow. I want to I want to talk about the Q3 report, but I want to start with little history about how we got to the marketplace here and that'll give context for what's interesting about this report today. So the Beginning of the athenahealth marketplace, Jonathan Bush was the CEO of athenahealth, and he was really into disruptive innovation. And over at Harvard Business School, there was Clayton Christensen, and he was studying disruptive innovation.
And so Clayton Christensen would come over to the athenahealth headquarters and Jonathan and him would talk about these things. So they came up with this program called More Disruption Please. And the idea was if you can invite the companies that would otherwise disrupt you into the platform and exist on the platform, it would reduce the chances of any one of those companies displacing athenahealth because they would then be reliant on the network and on the platform. So that They launched that. the name More Disruption Please was confusing for people because a lot of practices are like, we we don't need more disruption right now.
Chaos is not a fri our friend.
Exactly. but it worked and they got out there and it's grown and it's grown and athenahealth's gone through different iterations and changes and is now a privately held company, A PE backed. But the marketplace has kept chugging along and it continues to grow. And that is part of what we saw in the Q3 report, is that More and more practices are buying services from the athenahealth marketplace. So there were 870 new practices that signed up with the marketplace partner in Q3, and that brings them up to over 26,000 total practice to marketplace partner connections, which is really impressive. And then in total, there are 30 partners that joined and 11 partners that departed.
So there's still a healthy growth side happening on the marketplace.
Very cool. what what do you think has fueled this sort of last round? I think, you know, we joined the marketplace a year or so ago, and like my sense is that like that's accelerating. what's the impact of AI and or sort of just healthcare tech in general that you think, you know, athenahealth's either is there a tailwind there that's sort of pushing that into the marketplace, or is there something unique about the marketplace because you've kind of seen it from both sides that attracts, you know, an an outsized sort of share of that growth?
So I'd say it's both things. So f as far as the attracting growth, athenahealth publishes great documentation on their APIs and makes it easy to sign up. And there is they accept most people onto the marketplace. If you're not gonna like break something, they generally accept most people onto the marketplace. And other marketplaces are More intentional on who they bring in because they're trying to curate and build something. And so because of that, athenahealth's creating an opportunity there. Next, athenahealth is obviously Epic is the gorilla in the room. They're the largest EHR. They're really focused on the hospital space. athenahealth is the largest EHR in the private practice ambulatory space. And so when these companies come up, And they want volume in order to grow their business if that's they want to go where the customers are. And if athenahealth is where the customers are, and you can go to a website and read those APIs, it attracts more people to come in and to build there. Now the last part about ChatGPT.
So I actually I had a blog post about this. I'm gonna share a graph and I'm gonna update this again at the end of this year, because I think it's really fascinating stuff.
Half of athenahealth Marketplace partners had joined since ChatGPT launched.
Which is incredible. this is lowering the barrier of entry to create SaaS products for people. And it just absolutely took off. And so I think that's one place that AI has come in. there's another category too where AI as a tool allows us to solve problems that previously didn't have good solutions before, or solution problems that just humans were able to solve. And so now there's this opportunity to just imagine.
Brand new ways of doing things and ways to solve problems. And if you solve one problem, that creates a different scenario that can create a different problem to solve or another solution. Or it just has cascading effects as we go through this AI adoption change.
Yeah. And the thing I I think the thing that we're seeing that and for sure our own experience is that the AI allows you to solve these problems uniquely at scale, right? Where normally every practice was like a little different and a little bit of a snowflake, and you're like, man, a a typical SaaS tool couldn't really solve any of these problems well. So it always felt like the solution and the problem kind of was like, they kind of don't fit, but we kind of, you know, tweak the solution or we tweak the the problem to force it to fit. And there were so many of these forced fit problems. And now with AI, you're like, I can exactly build exactly what they want. And I it's funny because you the ChatGPT thing reminds me of another thing you had wrote was this whole the death of Chrome extensions, right? And we were at Thrive last year, athenahealth's like, man, all these companies are building Chrome extensions to work around APIs or work around the comp, just the approach to take because they just built the company the old way, which is like, man, if I can't get inside, I'm just going to, spam the browser with, a Chrome extension type of request. what's the failure mode that you've seen from that? And then I'd love to talk about the opposite side, which is the sort of breadth of APIs that athenahealth has.
Yeah, so the Chrome extension and robotic process automation RPA is a really fascinating space. There and my thinking has evolved on this over time as the technology has evolved and changed. I started out with a lot of concern, just the increased attack surface of running a Chrome extension and the people at the practices not knowing as much about their n network security as as as someone who like when you install the that web browser extension and it opens you up to a lot of different things. If you don't know what that is and you don't know what that risk is and you don't trust the person who you're getting that access to, it could lead to challenges. You also have problems with the computer's using like computer vision. So it's actually like reading all of the code that loads the website, the DOM, or it's actually like looking at a screenshot of what it is and interpreting where to go from there. And so if athenahealth moves things around, that can break that process.
Inherently fragile, right? fragile by design. Yeah.
Yes, exactly. And so that that raised a lot of concerns for me up front. And then there are also issues from the athenahealth side where athenahealth reviews all of the workflows that partners submit via APIs ahead of time. And so they're checking to see if something's gonna break. And If it's going through a different, if it's going through a Chrome extension, there are not those fail-safes. There's not the chance to check something before it's going to break. And you you can see it from the inside when all of a sudden there's like a number of requests that no human could possibly make in a short period of time that are happening. Like, this is a robot. Like we need to approach this bug in a different way because this is clearly a robot doing this from the outside.
Yeah. And so now looking at the the way that athenahealth wants you to do it, you these APIs, right? There's eight hundred and thirty-eight APIs on the athenahealth marketplace, which is crazy. I think we support almost all of them now. I think we're at 828 or something, or 829. There's a couple we didn't do. and we've gone through that approval process, you know, in batches, obviously, 800 times individually to show and demo that those worked. when you look at, you know, and work with kind of your customers and and have seen companies going approach that, like What are the sort of benefits of going down that route? And then where do folks fall into trouble? Cause I think you said it, there's there's a lot of docs, but 800 APIs. come on, there's a that's a lot of functionality. And I think the depth of an EHR like athenahealth that covers so many specialties, so many practices and so many use cases, the permutations, I don't even can't even do the math of the combinations of the that exist there, which also leads to like.
athenahealth itself and the way it's implemented by practice is incredibly complex and differentiated. what advice would you give to other, company founders out there or other vendors out there that are building against that? How to navigate that, crazy matrix at at some level?
Yeah, it's a great question. At the end of the day, you're even though when you're building it, you're looking at the API documentation and the workflows and the sandbox environment of the practice you're working with, ultimately you're changing a process of a human on the other side of it.
And that is where a lot of the challenges really come from. It all ends up ch turning into an ops problem on the other side. And so really getting to understand what those workflows look like is really important and what work what the human's experience on the other side is gonna be. Because ultimately that human's gonna be the one who tells their friends that it's a good service or not, or if they stick with you or not. So you have to get that going.
And then there's another piece too, which is just knowing what is going to be differentiated between clinics and what is not. I was working with a company that is a payments company, and they've come up with a really great way to collect more, collect the money that patients owe, but collect it earlier and a higher percentage of it. So practices love this. They had I was working with them when they had two customers and their customers were asking them to build new scheduling functionality. They wanted a better scheduling interface for the front desk folks to use. And I told them, like, scheduling is really difficult. There are whole companies that are dedicated to just doing scheduling. you really wanna make if you're gonna wade into this space, you wanna make sure that you're double down.
That you're really gonna commit the engineering time to solve all of these problems because client three, four, five, ten, fifteen is gonna have different scheduling requirements and they're personal things. Sometimes the scheduling is Dr. Jones wants to go to his kids' soccer practice Tuesday at 4:30, and so that's like that's really important to Dr. Jones, and so that schedule needs to work within that way.
They continued building it out for a little while and then they paused and realized how many tickets were coming in and said, Okay, right now we're focused on the payment side. We're just gonna stay focused on that. and it was successful. They went from two to thirty customers over the next 12 months.
Yeah, I think the focus is cool. It's funny, like you say scheduling. So we start with scheduling and voice, which is the two trickiest, right? It's like the crazy matrix of scheduling and then doing that in real time with voice talking to patients. And we picked that for the same reason you said is that if you can solve that, then all the other problems become easier because they're asynchronous or they're a smaller subset of complexity. And I'm curious, as you and our view is that, to your point, you once you get into a practice and you start working with them.
They naturally want you to solve all the adjacent issues and all the adjacent problems, right? And so, a lot of times they don't, and I think you've said this before, they don't buy an efficiency pitch, right? that's not the way they think about their work. It's like, hey, can you help me complete this workflow? Can you help me serve my patients better? Can you help me, optimize my provider's time to exactly whether you match the soccer match? We have a customer who, on Thursdays, If there's no pediatric patients, then they want to go home, right? and go early because tomorrow they're gonna be at a school. And so they do that differently, right? And so it's crazy, the nuances of those.
what happens when athenahealth starts building what your marketplace company sells, right? And I think you've written about this in a couple of different ways. And walk me through the playbook and say, okay, athenahealth announces the, key feature of what you think your product does or or where that goes. And, you call it like this awareness cloud. what happens with that? And and walk me through how you've approached that in the past. Cause I think you've seen this a couple of times now throughout the number of years you've been associated.
Yeah, absolutely. So When going back to some of the earlier history of the marketplace, when it first launched, part of the pitch was, hey, we're not going to build everything. We, athenahealth, are not going build everything. Help us fill in these gaps. And one of the areas was self-check-in. athenahealth just didn't build an online self-check-in experience. They relied on partners to do that. So we saw Phreesia, it started as a marketplace partner, is now a publicly traded company, Epion at the time, now owned by Kyruus.
Scooped up by RevSpring recently. Then
Yeah.
Qure4u came in later. Like all these companies started without being their core, their core offering to fill that gap. And then three, four, five maybe years ago, athenahealth said, hey, we're gonna enough practices have said, hey, you need to get build some self-check-in functionality that athenahealth decided to do it. And so they built out self-check-in functionality and It works. There are a lot of parts of parts of it that are really great, but there are certain features that don't match exactly what their customers want and need. And so that opens up a gap and a space for marketplace partners to come in and do a better job. In that case, there are already also a bunch of marketplace partners that are in place already. So you have to get someone to change what they're doing, which is always hard unless there's some other instigating thing driving that actual change.
So that's that's a version of what happened in the past. Now we have a whole suite of new products that athenahealth's launching that I believe they're developing faster because they're also on the AI boom. Like they also are using Claude Code and Codex. So they can work, their Scrum teams can push out more features faster. And so they can be more competitive, not as competitive as what's going on in the marketplace, but more competitive. And So they announced two-way texting as an example where you can buy an add-on or they're developing it an add-on from athenahealth, and it's basically like Slack, but when you send a message, it goes to the patient's phone number. So the front desk can have this really fluid asynchronous conversation with practices. And companies that have been doing this, And people love that. But athenahealth coming out with a native version of it, it's gonna be interesting to see whether this actually does a displacement piece. Otherwise, the other thing and what I've seen in a lot of places is practices aren't dialed into everything that's going on in the marketplace, but they listen more to what athenahealth's coming out with. So when athenahealth's like, hey, we're doing two-way texting, there's a whole swath of practices that would be like, holy cow.
We can do two-way texting, that's incredible. And they'll they'll
Yeah.
look at it and they may go with athenahealth's, they may go with a third party, they may try athenahealth's, then be like, hey, I want these other features, and then go with third party. So that whole that whole space is is growing and developing. and and how the marketplace is impacted with athenahealth coming out with something is starting to change.
Yeah, it's cool. I think the two-way texting super resonates because we've, like you said, there's legacy practices, you know, vendors that have been out there for 10 years, they're trying to add AI. And then you have athenahealth launching a version. And what we've found is the customers, like we've now have two-way texting, but they don't have a they're not, it's not agentic two-way texting. So it's like you like you said, it's Slack, but then it's like, wait, you got Slack from like five years ago, you didn't get Slack with agents, which is what people expect. And so when they see, like, wait,
Yes.
now you can add agentic to it, where you know, if somebody just texts, I want to change my appointment.
There's no reason that should go to a human. You can just we can automate on the phone, you could automate that in texting. But you're right that those initial features, though both the legacy providers and athenahealth's initial version, only had deterministic rules where it was like, if they say this, say that. the old style IVR model where it's not like the true, conversational, hey, let's just, get the work done. but yeah.
Yes. So that is inside the world of the athenahealth marketplace, that is Clayton Christensen's disruptive innovation model happening. athenahealth
Yeah. Totally.
created a terrarium, and now we're watching that next iteration of generations of life and that disruptive innovation happen. And that is able to happen because none of the partners in the marketplace own the relationships with the practice. It's all filtered through athenahealth.
Which is still owns those core relationships. And
Absolutely. They're still there on the platform.
exactly. And I've been thinking a lot about what that means now. Because, like I s said before, when athenahealth first started launched the marketplace, it was a lot of fill-in-the-gap functionalities. But now we're starting to see More like the quality of what's in the marketplace is getting higher and higher every single day. And that's drawing more and more people to use all these things at the edge. So athenahealth still owns like the ledger in the middle, but the edge is getting really competitive. And that makes it hard when athenahealth's coming out with functionality to compete with what's going on at the edge. Now the practices.
Feel that. And they talk about something called total cost of ownership. This is how much does it cost to run athenahealth plus all of the marketplace vendors that you need to do the things that you want? And it's changing the place of where athenahealth is in in this game. athenahealth used to run all of the pieces. and now if the add-ons are so good, you want all those add-ons as well.
Yeah, I think the thing for us, it's so the total cost of ownership is funny, right? Because you you've done the MBA thing, so right? It's like, it's like cut costs, increase revenue, the ideal is both, right? So it's like, hey, if you can do something that saves you money, is more efficient, is more accurate, and it actually helps you grow your practice, right? Like a a good example for us, you can make phone calls and people can take phone calls and you can book an appointment. But then if you see a cancel, you can you know fill that hole before they even know it the cancel.
And now the provider sees, it's good for everybody, right? The patient gets a sooner appointment, the provider doesn't have a no-show. And then the practice didn't have to staff that operation. And then that can be autonomously just running. that's very hard for athenahealth to build at scale for a hundred and seventy thousand providers, thousands of organizations. They can do that sort of commodity version where it's like, hey, this is a good version that'll work pretty good for a lot of cases, but it's not going to hit that edge sort of bleeding best.
Capability and have the richest AI thing. So I think you're right. that is the magic of this training.
I think you've probably seen this right. customer will say, we support all EHRs, which means your your integration by definition must be very thin because like, you know, all EHRs is like hundreds if you take out these really niche ones and then, you know, tens, even if you pick like the first tier ones. You know, we made the choice kind of strategically up front to go in all on athenahealth, focus on athenahealth, and really, really go super, super deep with athenahealth. And that so far has, rewarded us with that kind of growth, which has worked out. I'm curious for you, as you look at the customers you work with, I'm guessing some of them are, like I said, in that case where it's like they're coming to athenahealth for the first time, but maybe they were successful in other EHRs. In other cases, they are venture backed and they're saying hey, we've got all this money and we need to go everywhere to make it look good to our investors and get logos and show that we have 17 integrations. And what have you can you educate sort of the the sort of other founders out there that are looking at this or other folks on the space, as they're navigating that, what's the benefit or or trade-offs that you've seen from your experience?
Yeah, so it depends how you how you come to it, how you come to be solving the problem in the first place and what your
Yeah.
connection to it is. So obviously you need a customer, and that customer is going to be a practice that is on a platform. And so ever whoever that first customer is, if you're you are likely to start trying to build it to that and then find whether that is successful or not.
If that first customer is on ECW, you're gonna go through a lot more work to get there. And you may end up going through Redox or Excalibur and API layer to make all those connections happen. if they happen to be on athenahealth, you're gonna be like, wow, there's all this API documentation. It's more complicated than we thought once we really got into it, but there's all this documentation there. and so because so when when People come to it through generally their sales process. If they've been in healthcare before, then they're gonna know who the players are. They're gonna know a little bit more about like which direction to be going in. or if they take a step back and they have that strategic moment, that strategic thinking, they talk to someone else who's in the industry, they can choose where they wanna go. Now, with athenahealth, it is.
single instance multi-tenant. So you build the inner interaction, you build the interface to athenahealth and then you can turn it on for the other athenahealth practices. And you deal with the configuration changes. but generally you can ex you can scale faster.
If you're going to ECW, some of those are run on an old server in the basement of the clinic. And so building interoperability
Yep. Closet.
there is a lot harder to do. And so you build a connection to one ECW client and you haven't built to the rest of their customer base. And so there's an interesting piece that comes into play there though, because it's easier to build to athenahealth.
There are more solutions. And so practices have a higher bar that you need to clear of the quality that you're providing them because there's a lot more competition. Opposed to ECW, like those people really need more help because they have a lower, not as many bells and whistles, core EHR. And so they're in ways, those problems, the if you run an ROI calculator, the numbers are going to come back way higher on those ECW customers, but the amount of effort that you're going to need to do to get there.
And then the amount of effort you're gonna need to do the next customer and the next one and the next one is gonna be high. So you have to think about your own margins of your company and not just the ROI of the particular practice.
Yeah, I like it.
We go if we go back to what I was talking about before, I'm gonna bring up some of my Q3 data here as well.
Yeah.
talking about like the ledger, the core of athenahealth, the these are the patients, these are their vital signs, these are the providers, these are the orders you can choose from, and then the edge of the like what you're doing. So all the incoming phones and outgoing phones and patient communication is more like on the edge of athenahealth has those offerings, but there's so much cool building going on on the edge there. Now one area, athenahealth, I'm gonna go back into the history again here for a second. So athenahealth started out as a clinic that couldn't get paid, an OB clinic in San Diego that couldn't get paid. And the software engineer Todd Park and Ed Park were brothers. Ed Park sat down with our biller and she told she had all of the rules. Blue Cross Blue Shield California won't pay this unless you have a prior authorization. You need to have a 52 in box 89 and just like all these rules. And he wrote code that was like, these are all of the rules you need to follow. And then before any claim went out to go to a payer, you had to conform to those rules. And that greatly reduced denials.
And that was that was the core functionality was the athenaCollector Rules Engine.
So you'd think that that is that's the sacred thing. That's the core at the center, it's the nucleus of of what they've built. But when we look at the data, there are a lot of revenue cycle companies that are on the athenahealth marketplace now. And that is fascinating because that means that people have found better ways to do the core offering that athenahealth originally came to market with.
And that is they st athenahealth still holds because they have the customers and they are the ledger and they are the core piece. But even the main feature that they're offering is starting to get is starting to get pushed on a little bit. So if we look
Yeah, I would love to bring up the Q3s that remind as you're bringing that up, it reminded me of the story. So when we got we saw my last company on Microsoft and for it to be come on mobile outlook, and there was this add-ons market for Excel and Word. And I'm like, wait, these are things that have been around forever. how can Excel or Word be missing features? Right. And there were things on there that would extend the spreadsheet with other spreadsheet functionality. And it was like, but it's to your point, these platforms get so large.
There's always going to be niche or small things or just innovative things that can be done, which is is pretty cool to see. So yeah, what are we looking at here? Let's walk into this.
Yeah. So we are and yeah, there just are always things that can be done. And the things change too. if you're buying athenahealth is like buying a Cadillac. It has all of these features and bells and whistles. But if you don't know how to use all of them, what really matters? And if they're known for building a stereo, if the RCM engine is the stereo, but now people are buying aftermarket stereos, it's like and similar with Microsoft. It's the same thing with all these plugins. It
Very similar.
can do everything, but people don't necessarily want everything or they want one specific.
So looking at this data, this is connection by category. So this is how many athenahealth practices bought solutions in this category. one for so AI phone agents in just exploded. this is what how many connections there were in Q3 versus Q2.
went from plus twenty-eight connections to plus a hundred and fifteen connections. And that matches with we just saw a lot of people flooding into the vo AI phone agent space in Q2. And so people are really seeing the value there. They're they were letting go of their fear of having the AI answer the phone at the practice. And and so it's cool to watch that that explode. Yeah.
Yep. And the tech's working. I mean, what that I I think two years ago those companies weren't possible, right? The voice and the ability to build real time voice AI that was deeply integrated with athenahealth just wasn't possible two years ago.
Yes, absolutely. And now it is. we're also seeing a lot of medical device and diagnostics companies. So a lot of these fall into the cardiac space. So like Holter monitors, like you have a cardiac event, you go to your cardiologist, they stick a little widget on you. That widget tracks your heart and reports it all
Yeah.
out afterwards. They're now building their own in-app.
experience for how you how the doctor goes through that data opposed to just like sending in a PDF. So we're seeing a lot of growth there. The AI clinical documentation, like the AI scribes are continuing to grow. And the patient engagement sections continue to grow too.
You think about scribes? Like, I think the early version we've had a scribe on our phone for 10 years, record something, transcribe it, Google translate, Google, voice to text. And the thing that I've heard, like the early version of scribes, like we're very good at like taking a blob of text and putting it in a box. And I think what practices are looking for now is this more advanced thing where it's like, hey, let me say something and actually go put it in all the right boxes and actually do the thing. Like it's more than just like dumping text in a box. Like, I'm curious what you're seeing around scribes and how that's changed in the time you've been around, athenahealth.
Yes, so scru when I first when I was first working at athenahealth, people were still using like dictation in the microphones, and then
Yeah.
they'd ship it off to a person to transcribe it, and then athenahealth came up with like built-in electronic version of those workflows. So it's it's come a really long way. And it's gonna keep getting better. I see the whole physician interface.
provider interface with the EHR is changing right now. And that's one of the edges that exists. There's the core ledger and then you have the physician interface that is moving to be more conversation based, more specific to that patient, bringing in evidence from other places that the doctor may not pull together in order to advise them on how that works. And so I think we're going to continue to see changes in in how that whole area operates. And that is one one of the places that pushes down on the ledger. The other side is we're having these RCM companies that are coming up that are doing
Yeah.
a better job at the bottom. And so then the ledger sits in the middle. And then we have like the patient engagement companies that are doing all of the communications with the patients and the quality there is changing. And then you have the like the HIEs or the anything that's going out to other lab, an imaging facility, another provider.
Yeah, charting, referrals, all this stuff, yep.
And so all of these edge pieces are getting super powered. And practices are building it kind of like back in the show, like Power Rangers. There's like the megazord, you like build it
Yeah.
from all the different components. Yeah, exactly. but then who's actually managing the inside of that? Who's who's is there an operations person?
So the the physician interaction part is really important. And that area blew up because physicians wanted it. And they told their bosses, hey, we need to have this. This is going to save me a ton of time. And so they they managed to get product-led growth in an industry that's notoriously hard to do product-led growth in because there are so many checkpoints. But They didn't want to be charting in their pajamas anymore. And so they were they were able to make that happen. So there's there's a bright future on on the scribe side of things that I see.
Awesome. What else do you got on the data? Any other things that you want to highlight or show?
Yeah, so one thing I want to talk about is the revenue cycle management. So is this shows that there was a huge loss here. This was actually a a loss from one partner.
This was T S I, right? T S I just lost hundreds of like it just looks like they churned a couple, old connections or something probably.
Yeah, they lost three hundred and fifty-nine connections in that quarter. And if they hadn't lost those, RCM would have been up a hundred and eight. And
Yeah, TSI is I think the biggest, they're like the collections agency essentially for athenahealth is where they've they've had that moat for a long time.
Yeah, so they predate the marketplace. athenahealth was like, hey, we need a partner in collections. We're just gonna build an interface. So any claim that gets sent to collections just gets pushed across the interface and lots of practices signed up for it. so something else, something happened there. That was like an administrative change or something shifted on that side. but it hides this RCM growth.
And that's what we see. We see these revenue cycle companies come in that if they can collect the money before the appointment happens, you're not sending someone to collections on the back end and everyone feels better about it. No one wants to send someone to a collections agency. No one wants to get sent to a collections agency.
No, in our in our web scheduler, I would say half the customers deploy that with payment, where it's like if you're booking an appointment, just pay the copay right up front as part of the making the appointment. And so you book the appointment if it's urgent care, if it's Botox, there's a lot of cash pay stuff. It's like just pay for it online. People are used to on their phone, click, click, two Apple Pays. They'd actually prefer to just get it done. It's not like they're trying to avoid it. And convenience, you know, is way better than chasing them with a stick later, which is like kind of the old approach to collections.
Absolutely. And it's just the path. You make it easy for people. Sometimes you make it too easy to tip 20% on a cup of coffee someone just hands you. Like people are guided by these systems. Not yet.
Well, yeah, that's at least there's no tipping at the doctor yet. So hopefully we we know, not yet, so
yeah, looking at the top gainers by growth, gotta gotta shout you out. The Pretty Good AI came in second place with 104% growth.
Thanks. Yeah, it's it's moving through it, so it's fun.
anything else you wanted to talk through or click through here that's interesting?
if we look at the partner turnover by category, you'll see that generally there are a lot more partners joining than are leaving. but then there are some people like in the AI phone agent space that hooked up Claude to ElevenLabs and thought they were gonna be able to run with it and realized that it was a lot harder than than they thought it was going to be. So we we see that coming in in a few different places here and in the category used to expect, the ones that have AI and workflow automation and practice up practice operations.
Then if we come down to the state of the marketplace, this is the distribution of practices across or of company types across the whole marketplace and how many connections they have. Patient engagement is still at the top spot. You talked about the the big original Phreesia Epion.
Qure4u, they they fall into that patient engagement category. And so there's still a lot of better practices on there. But then that AI clinical documentation has had a lot of adoption and we're seeing AI phone agents and workflow automation start to grow more and more as as time goes on.
Awesome.
then ratings activities, the ratings on the athenahealth marketplace are interesting.
I think this was yeah, most people don't do it.
Most people don't do it. they use a Bayesian average system for the marketplace and so for the marketplace ratings. So Rel the score of the rating is relative to the scores of the rest of the companies that are on the marketplace. And so it pulls everyone up artificially to the average. And what that does, and and this part is good. If a brand new company joins the marketplace and they get a one-star review, they're not gonna show up as one star because it's gonna pull towards the overall average. And that's That's reasonable. People are still figuring things out. You don't want one or two bad reviews to tank
Totally.
a company that only has four reviews total. however, once you're once we're up at scale and you're making choices, you look at it and you expect it to be like an Amazon rating for a pair of like a cable you're buying, but really that's not what it is. It all of a sudden becomes less useful on the whole. So, because of that, people don't spend as much time getting ratings. but So when I look at this, for me, what I read into that is these are the companies that are like really engaged with their customers that are really caring about what's going on and wanting people to have a good experience and are have a process in place to be doing that work. So I would actually I think that this data is most interesting to practices that are looking to buy, just seeing the volume of who's getting reviews right now, opposed to like what those reviews are.
It was funny. I talked to a practice couple weeks ago and this woman, she was like, Wow, you have lots of reviews and they're like from this year. Cause you go to somebody's with
Yes.
hundreds of reviews and you're like, wait a minute, they haven't had a new review in five years. That's weird. how do they have three hundred reviews, but they're like, so there is this weighting of you have recent reviews from different practices that are actually large? Cause the other thing you'll see is a lot of these scribes and stuff will have lots of them, but it's like provider one, a lot of single provider, where they're like, that doesn't map to somebody who's like looking at something with thirty-five docs or fifty docs or a hundred docs. And so I think it it is funny that the reviews end up being telling a story, even though in many cases there's not that many. It's like, are they recent? Are they have customers that are my size or my specialty? That helps give them some clear pause because yeah, over half the vendors have zero reviews or and zero ratings.
Yes.
more than half. Yeah. It's crazy.
The recency is interesting too. a lot of times the person who was getting the reviews stopped working at the company and that was not included in the handed off responsibilities to the backfill.
Awesome. Max, last question for you. and then definitely we'll put all links to this in the show notes to what you know where to find you, your LinkedIn. And I think, you know, you're very prolifically posting on this stuff. And so anybody who's interested in athenahealth marketplace, definitely gotta go follow Max on LinkedIn and see the latest. But where, you know, run us forward a few years, right? You've been in this space for a while, right? Like come out a year, two, three years from now. Like, what do you think marketplace categories are gonna hockey stick? And then where do you just see for the The sense of where this is going in the coming years from where where you sit today.
Yeah, so There's this building arms race in the RCM side between payer AI and provider AI. And so I think we're gonna continue to see that grow. We're gonna see more solutions that we haven't even thought of yet. That like people haven't applied these AI tools. Yeah, these AI tools are getting better and better.
I think some of that well, APIs are the safer, better way to go about doing this. If athenahealth and other EHRs are not creating more APIs to satiate the demand, people are going to start using RPA to a greater and greater extent. And the quality of that RPA is gonna get better. Like what Claude can do, go pulling up a Chrome window and clicking around and configuring things is.
Everything, literally everything, right? at this point, yeah.
I I set up a connection between GitHub and AWS and I had it just go do all the configuration and it came back in a few minutes and it was done and I was like, holy cow. That's
Read all the docs, clicked all the right buttons, checked all the right things and was like, Thank you.
Yes. And I was like, this is a low stakes thing. if it breaks, it's fine. I can clean up what it is. And it didn't break. It just did it all right and required some trust on my side. So seeing things like that and that that's gonna grow, I think we're gonna see more in the RPA space of of improving solutions that we hadn't seen otherwise.
When I think of this, as as I've gotten deeper into this, I love thinking about how it's gonna change the healthcare industry on the whole. So Epic has APIs, but it's not as open as what athenahealth is. So athenahealth is this, we talked about the terrarium, it is this little experiment of what happens when you have this marketplace, and then the there are these trade-offs and these different companies that are competing. How does that play out on the broader spectrum? the governments come in and said, Hey, you need to open up APIs to share clinical data with.
different partners, but maybe they'll come in and say you need to share RCM data. Maybe they're gonna start bringing down the walls that have created these companies that have been able to exist artificially long times because of regulation and regulatory capture. So that that's where that's what I'm really excited to see happen over the next five or ten years and to and to be part of that change.
Awesome. Max, this has been wonderful. Thank you so much for spending some time with me and excited to continue the conversation.
Yeah, thanks for having me on, Kevin
That was incredible. What a data-packed conversation to walk through with Max.
So, five takeaways that I came up with. One, the athenahealth marketplace is still booming. 870 new practice connections in Q3 alone, 26,000 in total, and 30 partners joined versus only 11 that left.
AI phone agents exploded. 115 new connections in Q3, up 28 in Q2. Pretty Good AI was number two on the fastest grower overall in the entire marketplace and the fastest growing AI company. Half of the marketplace partners joined after ChatGPT launched. So really AI just lowered that barrier to build, and practices are actually consuming what's being built.
athenahealth owns the ledger, startups own the edge.
What Max is seeing is that texting, scribes, RCM and phones is where the innovation's happening. 3,000 athenahealth devs can't match the startup speed.
go deep, not wide. When others say we support all EHRs, that really means thin integrations, RPA, Chrome extensions, they're just fragile by design. It's real APIs on one platforms that win.
if you're building on athenaOne or thinking about it, Go check out Max's marketplace intelligence report.
The link is in the show notes. And if that was useful, subscribe to the Pretty Good AI podcast so you can catch the next one. That's it for the show. I'm Kevin Henrikson from Pretty Good AI. See you next time.
Transcribed from the episode recording, with names and spellings corrected.